I was intrigued by the different journalistic takes on yesterday’s event. The news search results from Ask.com show some interesting variations and evolution:
Washington Post - Found 1 hour ago (Registration)
Calif. -- A heavily traveled section of freeway that funnels traffic off the San Francisco-Oakland Bay... intense enough to melt part of the freeway and cause the collapse, but the truck's driver...
Fire From Crash Collapses Calif. Freeway
ABC News - Found 27 minutes ago
intense enough to melt part of the freeway and cause the collapse, but the truck's driver...
(This revised headline says it better, right? Oh, wait—maybe, as the story text indicates, it’s a tiny bit of overstatement to imply that the whole Freeway collapsed)
A section of freeway that funnels traffic off the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge collapsed early Sunday after a gasoline tanker truck overturned and caught fire beneath it, authorities said.
MSNBC - Found 1 hour ago
intense enough to melt part of the freeway and cause the collapse, but the truck's driver... a 250-yard section of the roadway to collapse onto the roadway below, according to the highway...
(Now we’re getting specific—that headline won’t fit on the Oakland Tribune front page, though)
Calif. road collapses after tanker fire
MSNBC - Found 1 hour ago
Calif. - A section of freeway that funnels traffic off the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge collapsed... intense enough to melt part of the freeway and cause the collapse, but the truck's driver...
(Yah, it’s shorter, but it doesn’t adequately convey the seriousness of the situation. After all, this is a major traffic interchange, isn’t it?)
SF bridge interchange collapses
USA Today - Found 57 minutes ago
(AP) - A heavily traveled section of freeway that funnels traffic off the San Francisco-Oakland Bay... intense enough to melt part of the freeway and cause the collapse, but the truck's driver...
(SF? Hmm. Frisco’s impacted, for sure, but we’re losing our focus. Did that whole interchange fall down?)
Fire From Crash Melts Calif. Freeway
Daily Advance - Found 35 minutes ago
Fire From Crash Collapses Calif. Freeway By MARCUS WOHLSEN Associated Press Writer OAKLAND, Calif. A stretch... intense enough to melt part of the freeway and cause the collapse, but the truck's driver...
Channel 3000 - Found 38 minutes ago
Oakland side of the Bay Bridge. A freeway interchange that funnels traffic off the bridge collapsed...
CBS 11 News - Found 29 minutes ago
(CBS News) SAN FRANCISCO A freeway interchange that funnels traffic off the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge... fire was intense enough to weaken the freeway and cause the collapse, the truck's driver walked...
Freeway At San Francisco Bay Bridge Collapses
KUTV - Found 1 hour ago
FRANCISCO - A heavily traveled section of freeway that funnels traffic off the San Francisco-Oakland Bay... intense enough to melt part of the freeway and cause the collapse, but the truck's driver...
I thought it was particularly poignant that on the Channel 4 News Sunday morning, just a few hours after the fire, the newscasters were using “Google Earth” to show viewers what had occurred. An interesting testament to the complexity of the “MacArthur Maze” is that they reported that travel in three directions was blocked by the collapse, when in fact only two directions were affected. Looking out my livingroom window I could clearly see traffic coming around the curve onto 580 from southbound I-80. The maze will do that to you—you look at it and make what seem to be reasonable assumptions about what road does what—but they are wrong.
So, I figured the reporters and authorities just needed to be given a chance—later in the afternoon I checked online for a comprehensive description of what was open and what was closed—it was nowhere to be found. Even today, with extended wakeup TV newscasts, the discussion remains rather incoherent, with both drivers and newspeople pitching the greatest possible gloom and hysteria. Strangely, no one yet has uttered the T word.
The MacArthur Maze, as seen from above. That’s the hand of Allah gripping the affected portion. Red arrow shows our location.
1 comment:
A side note on journalism in the age of internet news: I think journalists and editors are beginning to pay attention to writing "keyword-rich copy."
In search advertising, this is a term for writing that contains repetitions of key words that people are likely to search for, so that your site will show up high in search results.
Journalists do it, too -- at least I did, when I was at internetnews.com, an online tech news site.
When you go to Google News, you see "Top Stories," and in each of those, one story is highlighted, or you can click for "more stories on this topic." Well, being that lead story gets you lots of readers.
If I were writing a story on the interchange collapse anyway, I might just look at what was leading Google News and, if there weren't too many on the topic, try to make sure my story included words they were using, like "fiery" and "collapse."
This is another example of how the importance of search is mutating content.
Post a Comment